Conic Sections: Star problems
Ten optional challenges to stretch your reasoning. Work on paper, use hints when you need them, and check the answer or full solution when you are ready. You can skip these problems and continue the course.
- 1 of 3 stars: Stretch
- 2 of 3 stars: Challenge
- 3 of 3 stars: Deep challenge
Stars indicate difficulty within this set.
0 of 10 completed · 0 skipped
Progress saved in this browser.
Progress can't be saved in this browser, so your choices last for this visit only.
-
Problem 1 A circle through two crossings
Difficulty: 1 of 3 stars, Stretch
The circles and meet at two points and . Find every circle through both and that is tangent to the -axis. Give its center and radius, and prove that your list is complete.
Text description of this figure
Coordinate axes. A larger circle is centered at the origin, which is labeled O. A smaller circle is centered at the marked point (6, 0) on the positive x-axis. The two circles cross at two points: A above the x-axis and B below it, mirror images of each other in the x-axis.
Builds on Circles
- Hint 1
Subtract the two circle equations before solving for either intersection.
- Hint 2
A center equidistant from and lies on their perpendicular bisector. Tangency to the -axis makes the radius equal to the absolute value of the center's horizontal coordinate.
Answer
Exactly one circle: center and radius .
Full solution
Subtracting the first equation from the second gives , hence .
Substitution gives , so and .
Write the center of any circle through these points as .
Equality of its squared distances to and gives , forcing .
Its squared radius is therefore
This describes every possible circle through the crossings, because either distance determines a positive radius.
The distance from to the -axis is .
Tangency is therefore equivalent to , which gives , or .
Thus and .
These values satisfy both point conditions and the tangency condition.
The center is not assumed to lie on a particular side of the axis; the equation has already exhausted both possibilities.
Answer
Exactly one circle: center and radius .
Key idea
Subtracting equal-degree distance equations often turns a family of circles into a one-variable problem.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 2 A broken path through a parabola
Difficulty: 1 of 3 stars, Stretch
A parabola has focus and directrix . A point may be anywhere on the parabola, and is fixed. Find the least possible value of , and find every point that attains it. Justify the minimum geometrically or algebraically.
Text description of this figure
Coordinate axes with an upward-opening parabola whose lowest point is at the origin. The focus F, labeled (0, 2), is marked on the positive y-axis. The directrix, the horizontal line y equals negative 2, is drawn dashed below the x-axis. A point P on the right arm of the parabola, level with F, is joined to F by a horizontal segment and to the fixed point A, labeled (6, 5), by a second segment, making a broken path from F to P to A. The point A lies above the right arm of the parabola, inside its cup.
- Hint 1
Replace by the distance from to the directrix.
- Hint 2
If , then . Determine when this inequality can be an equality, and check the corresponding point on the parabola.
Answer
The minimum is , attained only at .
Full solution
For a point on the parabola, the focus-directrix equation is , so and .
Consequently , with no absolute-value ambiguity.
The vertical separation is at most the full distance to :
Hence
The second inequality is an equality exactly when .
The first is an equality exactly when , since
On the parabola, forces , which does satisfy .
At this point and , so the lower bound is attained.
Every equality condition has been retained, so there is no second minimizing point.
The useful change was to replace one slanted segment by a vertical distance using the geometric definition of the parabola.
Answer
The minimum is , attained only at .
Key idea
When a conic is defined by distances, use that definition before replacing everything by coordinates.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 3 A triangle with a tilted fixed base
Difficulty: 1 of 3 stars, Stretch
An ellipse consists of points whose distances to and add to . Two other points, and , are fixed. Find the greatest possible area of triangle , and determine every maximizing point .
You may use the coordinate-area fact that this triangle has area . Prove a bound valid for the entire ellipse, and check its equality cases.
Text description of this figure
Coordinate axes with an ellipse centered at the origin, wider than it is tall. Its foci, F1 on the negative x-axis and F2 on the positive x-axis, are marked at equal distances from the origin. A triangle joins three points: A, labeled (0, 2), on the positive y-axis inside the ellipse; B, labeled (5, negative 1), near the right end of the ellipse just below the x-axis; and P, a point on the upper left part of the ellipse.
- Hint 1
First obtain the ellipse equation from its focal distances. The base is tilted, so maximizing alone is insufficient.
- Hint 2
Put and . Then . Expand .
Answer
The maximum area is , attained only at .
Full solution
Let and .
We have and , so and
Squaring and using gives
Put and , so .
The square identity
shows that
Consequently , and the triangle area is at most .
Notice that the negative endpoint, not the positive endpoint, produces the larger absolute value.
Equality requires and .
Solving gives , , hence
At this point the two focal distances are and , which sum to , so the point belongs to the original ellipse.
Its area is
All equality conditions force this single point, proving uniqueness without introducing extraneous points through squaring.
Answer
The maximum area is , attained only at .
Key idea
For a tilted geometric target, bound the corresponding linear expression on the conic and retain both signs until the end.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 4 Integer points beside an asymptote
Difficulty: 2 of 3 stars, Challenge
Consider the part of the hyperbola with and .
(a) Find all points on this part whose coordinates are integers, and find the least possible value of among them.
(b) If real coordinates are allowed instead, does have a least value? Prove your answer and explain its connection to the line .
- Hint 1
For integer coordinates, write and keep track of parity.
- Hint 2
For real coordinates, prescribe a positive value . Solve for and check when the reconstructed point has .
Answer
(a) ; the least value is . (b) No least value exists; can approach from above.
Full solution
Put and .
Because , we have , , and, for integer coordinates, and have the same parity.
Both must be even.
Also
The even divisors of below are , and their partners are all even.
Recovering and gives exactly .
The finite bound on proves completeness.
The minimum of is .
For real coordinates, choose any with and set ,
These values satisfy the equation, have the required signs, and give .
Therefore arbitrarily small positive values occur, but cannot occur because it would make .
The perpendicular distance to is .
Thus real points approach this asymptote without reaching it; the integer points have a positive minimum separation.
Answer
(a) ; the least value is . (b) No least value exists; can approach from above.
Key idea
An integer restriction can turn a continuous family with no minimum into a finite problem with an attained minimum.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 5 Midpoints of parallel chords
Difficulty: 2 of 3 stars, Challenge
A chord of the ellipse joins two distinct points, and its supporting line has slope .
(a) Find the exact locus of its midpoint, including which endpoints of the locus are excluded.
(b) Find all such chords whose length is , giving their endpoints.
Text description of this figure
Coordinate axes with an ellipse centered at the origin, wider than it is tall. A chord, labeled slope 3 over 5, rises from the lower left part of the ellipse to the upper right part, and its two endpoints on the ellipse are marked. Its midpoint, labeled M equals h, k, is marked on the chord a little to the right of the y-axis and a little below the x-axis.
- Hint 1
If the midpoint is , express the endpoints as and , with .
- Hint 2
Subtract the two ellipse equations to find a midpoint relation, then add them to relate to the midpoint. The chord length is .
Answer
(a) The open segment , . (b) Endpoints , or endpoints .
Full solution
Write the endpoints as with .
Subtracting their ellipse equations yields
Thus , or .
Averaging the equations then gives
Because the endpoints must be distinct, , so
Conversely, any in this open interval determines and a positive by the displayed formula.
Substitution shows that both endpoints lie on the ellipse.
This proves the full locus, not only a necessary equation.
At the two excluded endpoints the chord collapses to a single point.
The endpoint displacement is , so the chord length is .
Length forces , and then .
For the endpoints are ; for they are .
Both have the stated slope and length.
Answer
(a) The open segment , . (b) Endpoints , or endpoints .
Key idea
Expressing two endpoints as midpoint plus or minus a displacement separates position from direction.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 6 A chord through the focus
Difficulty: 2 of 3 stars, Challenge
The parabola has focus . A line through meets the parabola at two distinct finite points and .
(a) Prove that .
(b) Find the least possible chord length , and determine every chord attaining it. Your argument must include vertical lines and explain why the horizontal line is excluded.
- Hint 1
The directrix is , so a point on the parabola has focal distance .
- Hint 2
For a nonvertical line write . Use the sum and product of its two intersection inputs. Separately check .
Answer
(a) The reciprocal sum is always . (b) The least length is , attained only by the chord from to .
Full solution
The horizontal line through is , which meets the parabola only at its vertex, so it is not allowed.
For a nonvertical allowed line, with .
Substitution gives
If the intersection inputs are , their product is and their sum is .
The focal distances are and .
Therefore
To relate these distances to chord length, put .
The intersection equation is , whose two roots have opposite signs.
Hence lies between and , and
The remaining line is vertical: gives and .
Each focal distance is , so its reciprocal sum is also and its chord length is .
Thus the vertical chord is the unique minimizer.
It cannot be omitted merely because a slope parametrization misses it.
Answer
(a) The reciprocal sum is always . (b) The least length is , attained only by the chord from to .
Key idea
A root sum and product can reveal a geometric invariant, but omitted line directions need their own check.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 7 Circles between two boundaries
Difficulty: 2 of 3 stars, Challenge
A fixed circle has center and radius . A second circle has positive radius, lies in the closed upper half-plane, and is tangent to the -axis. It is externally tangent to the fixed circle, meaning the distance between their centers is the sum of their radii.
(a) Find the locus of the second circle's center.
(b) Find all such circles that are also tangent to the line . Give their centers and radii, and check that the contacts are external as required.
Builds on Circles
- Hint 1
If the second center is , its radius must be . Translate external tangency into an equation of distances.
- Hint 2
After squaring, the center locus is a parabola. Tangency to adds ; solve both sign cases.
Answer
(a) , with . (b) Centers , with corresponding radii .
Full solution
Tangency to the -axis and location above it make the radius , where .
External tangency to the fixed circle is
Both sides are positive, so squaring is reversible.
Simplifying gives .
The condition excludes .
Conversely every remaining point of this parabola gives a positive-radius circle satisfying the original distance condition; its lowest point has height zero.
Tangency to requires .
If , then , or , which has no real solution.
If , then , giving
Hence and
Both horizontal coordinates are less than , and both radii are positive.
For each candidate, implies that the center distance is exactly , rather than .
Thus the two circles touch externally, and all original tangency and half-plane requirements hold.
Answer
(a) , with . (b) Centers , with corresponding radii .
Key idea
A family of tangent circles can be encoded by a conic traced out by their centers.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 8 One meeting point is not always tangency
Difficulty: 3 of 3 stars, Deep challenge
Find every line through that meets the hyperbola in exactly one distinct real point. Give the meeting point for each line.
For each answer, determine whether substitution into the hyperbola produces a quadratic with a repeated root or a linear equation. Explain geometrically why the latter possibility occurs. Include the vertical line in your completeness check.
Text description of this figure
Coordinate axes with a hyperbola whose two branches open to the left and to the right. The branches cross the x-axis at their vertices, labeled negative 4 and 4. The point (0, 3) is marked on the positive y-axis, between the two branches. No asymptotes are drawn.
- Hint 1
Substitute , but do not apply the discriminant until you know the coefficient of is nonzero.
- Hint 2
The coefficient of vanishes when equals an asymptote slope. These exceptional slopes can still produce a single intersection.
Answer
Repeated-root lines: , with meeting points . Linear cases: at and at .
Full solution
The vertical line through is , which gives and has no real meeting point.
Every other line is .
Substitution and multiplication by give
If , this is a genuine quadratic.
Its discriminant is , which vanishes exactly at
The repeated input is , yielding points .
These are the two tangent lines detected by repeated roots.
If , the equation instead becomes , giving .
If , it becomes , giving .
The line slopes are the hyperbola's asymptote slopes.
Along these directions, cancellation removes the quadratic term; a translated asymptote can meet the hyperbola once without being a tangent.
All four listed points satisfy their original line and conic equations.
The vertical line, the two degenerate coefficients, and every genuine quadratic case have now been accounted for.
Answer
Repeated-root lines: , with meeting points . Linear cases: at and at .
Key idea
The degree of an intersection equation can change with a parameter; a discriminant test alone may miss valid cases.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 9 Two conics with the same foci
Difficulty: 3 of 3 stars, Deep challenge
The ellipse and hyperbola have the same two foci.
(a) Find the foci and every intersection point.
(b) At an intersection , show by algebra that the lines and each meet the corresponding conic only at . Then prove that these two contact lines are perpendicular. Do not use calculus.
Text description of this figure
Coordinate axes with an ellipse centered at the origin, wider than it is tall, and a hyperbola whose two branches open to the left and to the right from vertices close to the origin. Each branch rises and falls steeply through the ellipse, crossing it once above the x-axis and once below it. The curves are labeled ellipse and hyperbola, and the crossing points are not marked.
- Hint 1
Treat and as the unknowns in part (a).
- Hint 2
For part (b), set and use each line to express in terms of . The constant and linear terms in the conic equation cancel.
Answer
The common foci are , and the four intersections are , with signs chosen independently. The two displayed contact lines are perpendicular at each intersection.
Full solution
The ellipse has squared focal distance , while the hyperbola has squared focal distance , so both have foci .
Put and .
The equations become and , giving and .
Both are positive, so all four independent sign choices yield actual intersections.
Fix any intersection ; in particular .
On the ellipse contact line, write .
Since lies on the line,
Substitute this into the ellipse equation and subtract the equation at .
The result is
The coefficient is positive, so .
Thus this line meets the ellipse only at .
For the hyperbola line, the analogous substitution is , and subtraction gives
Here the coefficient is , so this contact is also unique.
The slopes are and .
Their product is
Hence the lines are perpendicular for every sign choice.
The contact equations were verified directly, so no tangent formula or derivative was assumed.
Answer
The common foci are , and the four intersections are , with signs chosen independently. The two displayed contact lines are perpendicular at each intersection.
Key idea
Shared geometric data can produce an algebraic relation between slopes that is invisible in either conic alone.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 10 The largest inscribed triangle
Difficulty: 3 of 3 stars, Deep challenge
Three distinct points on the ellipse form a triangle. Find its greatest possible area and give one maximizing triangle. Also characterize all maximizing triangles.
You may use the elementary fact that stretching every horizontal distance by and every vertical distance by multiplies every triangle's area by . Your bound must apply to all inscribed triangles, without assuming a side is horizontal. Do not use calculus or trigonometry.
Text description of this figure
Coordinate axes with an ellipse centered at the origin, wider than it is tall. A triangle is inscribed in it, with its three vertices marked on the ellipse: one at the right end of the ellipse on the positive x-axis, one at the top on the positive y-axis, and one on the lower left part of the ellipse.
- Hint 1
The coordinate change sends the ellipse to the unit circle. Solve the triangle-area problem there first.
- Hint 2
For a chord of the unit circle at distance from the center, the base is and the greatest possible height is . Set and factor .
Answer
The maximum is . One example has vertices . Equality holds exactly when the transformed vertices form an equilateral triangle on the unit circle.
Full solution
The stated scaling takes the ellipse to the unit circle and divides all areas by .
Consider any triangle on that circle, choose any one of its sides as a base, and let be the distance from the center to the base line.
Pythagoras gives base length .
The third vertex has distance at most from that line, with equality precisely at a circle point farthest from it; this point is unique when .
Thus the transformed area satisfies
Put , so .
Then
Hence
Equality requires and the third vertex at the farthest point.
The base then has length ; its half-length is and the height is , so each other side also has length .
These are exactly the equilateral triangles on the unit circle, all of which attain the bound.
Multiplying by gives maximum area and the stated equality characterization.
The displayed example is obtained by scaling the unit-circle vertices .
Choosing an arbitrary base made the bound independent of its direction.
Answer
The maximum is . One example has vertices . Equality holds exactly when the transformed vertices form an equilateral triangle on the unit circle.
Key idea
A coordinate stretch can turn a difficult shape into a symmetric one while preserving a controllable area ratio.
- Hint 1