Graphing Quadratics and Inequalities: Star problems
Ten optional challenges to stretch your reasoning. Work on paper, use hints when you need them, and check the answer or full solution when you are ready. You can skip these problems and continue the course.
- 1 of 3 stars: Stretch
- 2 of 3 stars: Challenge
- 3 of 3 stars: Deep challenge
Stars indicate difficulty within this set.
0 of 10 completed · 0 skipped
Progress saved in this browser.
Progress can't be saved in this browser, so your choices last for this visit only.
-
Problem 1 Two chords locate the vertex
Difficulty: 1 of 3 stars, Stretch
A parabola of the form , with , passes through , , , and .
Find its equation without solving three simultaneous equations. Then find the area of the triangle whose vertices are , , and the vertex of the parabola. Explain why your parabola is the only possibility.
Builds on Parabolas
- Hint 1
Equal heights reveal a symmetry line before any coefficients are known.
- Hint 2
Write . Compare the heights at horizontal distances and from the symmetry line.
Answer
; the triangle has area square units.
Full solution
For a quadratic, two distinct inputs with equal outputs lie equally far from its axis.
Indeed, subtracting their equations gives , so their midpoint is .
Both given pairs have midpoint .
Thus the equation must be
The outer pair gives ; the inner pair gives .
Subtraction gives , so and .
These values satisfy all four points, and the two independent height equations allow no other values.
The vertex is .
The triangle has horizontal base length and perpendicular height , so its area is
The height is a vertical distance, not the distance from the vertex to either end of the chord.
Answer
; the triangle has area square units.
Key idea
Use equal-output pairs to expose symmetry before expanding an equation.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 2 A direction with no preferred axis
Difficulty: 1 of 3 stars, Stretch
A circle passes through , , and . Find the greatest possible value of for a point on this circle, and find every point attaining it. Justify the maximum without calculus.
Builds on Completing the Square
- Hint 1
The center is equally far from each pair of the three known points.
- Hint 2
After translating to the center, compare with using .
Answer
The maximum is , attained only at .
Full solution
Let the center be .
Equal squared distances to and give , so .
Comparing with similarly gives .
The radius is , so the circle is
Put and .
Then and .
Since , we have
Hence
Equality in the square inequality requires .
To attain the upper bound their common value must be positive:
This pair lies on the circle and yields the stated point and value.
The equality conditions also prove uniqueness.
Answer
The maximum is , attained only at .
Key idea
A tilted direction can often be optimized by translating the figure and comparing two squares.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 3 Exactly one meeting point
Difficulty: 1 of 3 stars, Stretch
Find every nonvertical line through that meets the parabola in exactly one distinct real point. Give each line and its meeting point, and prove your list is complete.
Builds on Parabolas
- Hint 1
Write every allowed line using a single unknown slope.
- Hint 2
After substitution, exactly one meeting point means that a quadratic has a repeated real root.
Answer
, meeting at ; and , meeting at .
Full solution
Every nonvertical line through has the form for a real number .
A point is on both graphs precisely when , or
The coefficient of never vanishes, so the usual discriminant test applies for every slope.
There is exactly one distinct real solution if and only if
Thus or , giving or .
For the equation is and the common point is .
For it is and the common point is .
Both points satisfy their original line and parabola equations.
Since every permitted line was represented by , no other line can qualify.
The nonvertical condition matters: the vertical line would also have exactly one meeting point.
Answer
, meeting at ; and , meeting at .
Key idea
Translate a geometric count into the number of distinct real roots, and check excluded line types.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 4 Counting integer points below the axis
Difficulty: 2 of 3 stars, Challenge
For a real parameter , consider the parabola .
(a) Find all for which exactly four integer values of give a point strictly below the -axis.
(b) Can exactly five integer values of give such a point? Prove your answer.
Builds on Parabolas
- Hint 1
Reflection across the symmetry line pairs integer inputs.
- Hint 2
Compare the heights at with those at . Remember that points on the axis do not count.
Answer
(a) . (b) No; the number is always even.
Full solution
Write
The axis is , so the two inputs and always give the same height.
No integer is fixed by this pairing.
There are only finitely many points below the axis because the square eventually becomes larger than any fixed number.
They therefore occur in pairs, proving part (b).
For exactly four qualifying integers, the nearest four integers to must qualify and all others must fail.
These are .
The height at and is , so they qualify exactly when .
The next pair, and , has height , so it must satisfy .
If , the inner pair has height , while every integer outside is at least as far from the axis as or and has nonnegative height.
Thus the range is sufficient as well as necessary.
At the outer pair lies on the axis and does not count; at the pair no longer counts.
Answer
(a) . (b) No; the number is always even.
Key idea
Symmetry can force a parity restriction on a count before any roots are calculated.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 5 A rectangle under a curved roof
Difficulty: 2 of 3 stars, Challenge
A nondegenerate rectangle has sides parallel to the coordinate axes. Its two lower vertices lie on the -axis, and its two upper vertices lie on the parabola , above the -axis.
Find its greatest possible area and all rectangles attaining that area. Give an algebraic proof valid for every allowed rectangle; do not use calculus.
An example rectangle; its dimensions are not fixed. Text description of this figure
A pair of axes labeled x and y, with the origin marked 0. A downward-opening parabola, labeled y equals 12 minus x squared, has its highest point at 12 on the vertical axis and meets the horizontal axis on both sides of the origin. A shaded rectangle stands on the horizontal axis with its two upper corners on the parabola. The rectangle is one example only; its dimensions are not fixed.
Builds on Parabolas, Factoring by Grouping
- Hint 1
The two upper vertices have equal heights. What does that force about their horizontal positions?
- Hint 2
If the positive upper input is , the area is . Try comparing it with its value at and factoring the difference.
Answer
Maximum area square units; the unique rectangle has vertices , , , and .
Full solution
Let the upper vertices have horizontal coordinates .
Their heights agree, so , giving .
Since , we must have .
Write .
Positive height requires
Thus every allowed rectangle, including those not initially described as centered, has width and height .
Its area is
At this is .
To prove no other value is larger, calculate and factor the difference:
For the entire allowed interval , the factor is positive and the square is nonnegative.
Hence , with equality only when .
The resulting height is , yielding exactly the rectangle listed.
This proof optimizes a cubic expression using factoring; a graphing estimate alone would not establish the global maximum.
Answer
Maximum area square units; the unique rectangle has vertices , , , and .
Key idea
To certify a guessed maximum, factor the difference between that value and the general expression.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 6 Chords of a prescribed length
Difficulty: 2 of 3 stars, Challenge
Find all real numbers for which the line cuts the circle in a chord of length . For each qualifying line, give both endpoints of the chord. Prove that all possibilities have been found.
Builds on Parallel and Perpendicular Lines
- Hint 1
Find the foot of the perpendicular from the center to the line; it is also the chord midpoint.
- Hint 2
The radius, half-chord, and center-to-line distance form a right triangle. A direction vector along the line is .
Answer
: endpoints and . : endpoints and .
Full solution
A perpendicular to through the origin has points .
Its intersection with the line satisfies , so the foot is and
A perpendicular from a circle center bisects a chord: the two right triangles have the same hypotenuse and common perpendicular leg, so their other legs are equal.
The circle radius is and half the desired chord is .
Pythagoras gives , hence and .
This condition was necessary for every such chord.
A vector of length parallel to the line is , because has length .
For , the midpoint is ; adding and subtracting that vector gives and .
Negating these points gives the endpoints for .
The listed points satisfy both original equations and have distance , so both candidates work.
Answer
: endpoints and . : endpoints and .
Key idea
A chord-length condition is often simpler in a right triangle than in the two intersection equations.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 7 A parameter on a bounded window
Difficulty: 2 of 3 stars, Challenge
Find every real number for which the parabola is on or above the line at every input in the closed interval . Explain why considering only the endpoints is insufficient.
Builds on Quadratic Optimization
- Hint 1
Subtract the line height from the parabola height.
- Hint 2
The minimum on a closed interval occurs at the vertex when the vertex lies inside; otherwise use the nearer endpoint.
Answer
. Checking only the endpoints would incorrectly allow some .
Full solution
The vertical difference is
Its vertex has input .
We need throughout , so the location of this vertex determines the relevant minimum.
If , the vertex lies left of the interval, and the square in is smallest at .
We need , giving
If , the vertex lies inside.
Its value is
This is nonnegative exactly for ; intersecting with the current case gives
If , the minimum is at , where
There are no solutions in this case.
Combining the cases gives and proves sufficiency.
Endpoint checks alone give and .
For example, passes both checks, since and , but has , so it fails inside the window.
Answer
. Checking only the endpoints would incorrectly allow some .
Key idea
When optimizing on a restricted domain, first locate the vertex relative to that domain.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 8 When two intersections become four
Difficulty: 3 of 3 stars, Deep challenge
For each real radius , determine the number of distinct real intersection points of the parabola and the circle . Identify every radius at which the number changes, and justify all boundary cases.
Builds on Parabolas, Completing the Square
- Hint 1
The equations depend on through . Count possible values of first.
- Hint 2
Put . A positive value of produces two points, while produces only one.
Answer
Let . There are points for , for , for , for , and for .
Full solution
Substitute and set .
The circle equation becomes , or
If , the right side is negative, so there are no points.
At , the single value is positive and gives two points .
For larger radii the two candidate values are
The larger is always positive.
The smaller is positive precisely when , zero precisely when , and negative when .
Thus between the two thresholds, both values produce a pair of points: four in total.
At , the values are and .
They give and , so the total is three, not four.
For only the positive value is allowed, giving two points.
Every retained produces and satisfying both equations, so no extraneous or missing points remain.
Answer
Let . There are points for , for , for , for , and for .
Key idea
An auxiliary variable may merge several original solutions; keep track of how many each value represents.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 9 The smallest circle around an arc
Difficulty: 3 of 3 stars, Deep challenge
Consider the entire parabola arc consisting of all points with . Find the smallest possible radius of a circle whose closed disk contains this whole arc, and find all possible centers for that smallest radius.
The center is allowed anywhere in the plane. Your proof must cover every point of the arc, not just its endpoints and vertex.
Text description of this figure
A pair of axes labeled x and y. An arc of the parabola labeled y equals x squared runs from the point with coordinates negative 2 and 4 on the left, down through the origin, and up to the point with coordinates 2 and 4 on the right. The two endpoints and the vertex at the origin are marked with dots and labeled with their coordinates; the parabola is not drawn beyond the two endpoints.
Builds on Quadratic Optimization
- Hint 1
First investigate centers on the -axis, balancing the vertex against the two endpoints.
- Hint 2
For a general center , average its squared distances to the two arc points and . Then use to check the whole arc.
Answer
The minimum radius is , attained only by the center .
Full solution
First suppose the center is .
A disk containing the arc must contain its vertex and endpoints, so its squared radius is at least both and .
If , the first is at least .
If , the second is at least
Thus every center on the axis needs radius at least , and equality can occur only at .
At this candidate center, the squared distance to , with , is
Hence the proposed disk really contains the entire arc.
Now allow a center and radius .
For each , both reflected arc points must be in the disk.
Averaging their squared distances gives
Therefore the axis-centered disk with squared radius also contains the whole arc.
By the lower bound already proved,
In particular , and equality forces and then .
This proves global optimality and uniqueness without assuming the center is symmetric.
Answer
The minimum radius is , attained only by the center .
Key idea
Average constraints from reflected points to justify a symmetry reduction, then verify the entire set.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 10 The sharp parabola beneath a circle
Difficulty: 3 of 3 stars, Deep challenge
For a real number , let be the parabola or line .
(a) Find all for which every point on the circle satisfies . In particular, find the greatest such and all equality points for that greatest value.
(b) For every real , determine the number of distinct intersections of with the circle. Explain how the sharp value in part (a) appears in this count.
- Hint 1
The bottom point of the circle lies on every . Use to factor the vertical difference.
- Hint 2
The factorization is . On the circle, ; an interior height gives two points.
Answer
(a) Exactly ; the greatest is , with equality only at . (b) One intersection for , and three for .
Full solution
On the circle, substitute into the vertical difference:
For , the factor is nonnegative.
If , the other factor is at least .
If , then
Thus every works.
At , the difference is , so equality occurs only at the bottom point .
If , the number lies strictly between and .
Choose any height strictly between and .
Circle points at that height exist, and the first factor is positive while the second is negative.
Thus the proposed bound fails.
This proves sharpness, not merely that works.
For intersections, the bottom point always qualifies.
If , the second factor is never zero.
If , an additional height can only be .
For it exceeds ; for it is below ; at it repeats the bottom height.
For it is an interior height and gives exactly two further points, with
Hence the count changes from one to three immediately above the sharp value.
Answer
(a) Exactly ; the greatest is , with equality only at . (b) One intersection for , and three for .
Key idea
To prove a bound is best possible, establish both a universal inequality and a failure beyond the proposed constant.
- Hint 1