Geometry Basics: Star problems
Ten optional challenges to stretch your reasoning. Work on paper, use hints when you need them, and check the answer or full solution when you are ready. You can skip these problems and continue the course.
- 1 of 3 stars: Stretch
- 2 of 3 stars: Challenge
- 3 of 3 stars: Deep challenge
Stars indicate difficulty within this set.
0 of 10 completed · 0 skipped
Progress saved in this browser.
Progress can't be saved in this browser, so your choices last for this visit only.
-
Problem 1 Three perimeters, two deductions
Difficulty: 1 of 3 stars, Stretch
A rectangle is divided into four smaller rectangles by one horizontal cut and one vertical cut, each running all the way across it. The top-left, bottom-left, and bottom-right rectangles have perimeters 30 cm, 22 cm, and 34 cm, respectively.
(a) Find the perimeter of the top-right rectangle and the perimeter of the original rectangle.
(b) Do these three given perimeters determine the area of the original rectangle? Justify your answer. All lengths are positive.
Perimeters shown. Not to scale. Text description of this figure
A rectangle is divided into four smaller rectangles by one vertical line and one horizontal line, each running all the way across it. The perimeter of each small rectangle is written inside it: 30 cm in the top left, 22 cm in the bottom left, 34 cm in the bottom right, and a question mark in the top right. No side lengths are labeled, and the drawing is not to scale.
- Hint 1
Compare the top and bottom rectangles in the left column. Which side lengths cancel?
- Hint 2
The sum of the perimeters of two diagonally opposite small rectangles equals the perimeter of the large rectangle.
Answer
Top-right: 42 cm. Original rectangle: 64 cm. Its area is not determined; 256 and 252 square centimeters are both possible.
Full solution
The top-left perimeter exceeds the bottom-left perimeter by 8 cm.
The widths are equal, so twice the difference between their heights is 8 cm.
The top row is therefore 4 cm taller than the bottom row.
The same height difference applies in the right column, so its top rectangle has perimeter cm.
Take the top-left and bottom-right rectangles together.
Their perimeter expressions contain each column width twice and each row height twice.
That is exactly the perimeter of the original rectangle.
It is therefore cm.
The other diagonal pair confirms this: .
For area, choose column widths 5 and 11 cm, and row heights 10 and 6 cm.
The given small perimeters are correct, and the original area is square centimeters.
Alternatively, widths 6 and 12 cm and heights 9 and 5 cm give the same small perimeters but original area
Two valid constructions with different areas prove that the area is not determined.
Answer
Top-right: 42 cm. Original rectangle: 64 cm. Its area is not determined; 256 and 252 square centimeters are both possible.
Key idea
An invariant can determine one measurement while leaving another measurement free.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 2 An equilateral triangle inside a square
Difficulty: 1 of 3 stars, Stretch
The vertices of square are named in order around its boundary. Point lies inside the square, and , so triangle is equilateral.
Find angles and . Give an angle argument that proves your answers; do not measure a drawing.
Text description of this figure
A square ABCD, with A at the bottom left, B at the bottom right, C at the top right and D at the top left. A point P inside the square, close to the top side, is joined by segments to all four corners. Side AB and segments AP and BP each carry one tick mark, showing that they are equal. The angle at D between side DC and segment DP is marked with a question mark, and so is the angle at P between segments PD and PC.
- Hint 1
The square and the equilateral triangle give two angles at . What is angle ?
- Hint 2
Because , triangle is isosceles. Repeat the reasoning on the other side of the square.
Answer
Angle and angle .
Full solution
Every angle of equilateral triangle is .
The square has a right angle at , and is inside it, so angle is
All square sides have length , while .
Thus , making triangle isosceles.
Its two base angles, and , are each
At , segment splits the square's right angle.
Therefore angle is
Similarly, angle is , and .
Triangle therefore has angle , leaving angle
The angles of triangle sum to , so angle is
Each deduction follows from equal sides and angle sums, so the argument does not depend on the appearance of the drawing.
Answer
Angle and angle .
Key idea
Look for isosceles triangles created by equal lengths from different shapes.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 3 Inside the coordinate diamond
Difficulty: 1 of 3 stars, Stretch
Join the points , , , and in that order to form a diamond-shaped quadrilateral.
(a) Find its area.
(b) How many points with whole-number or negative whole-number coordinates lie strictly inside the quadrilateral? Points on its edges or at its vertices do not count. Explain a systematic count.
Text description of this figure
A pair of coordinate axes, with the origin labeled 0, drawn over a faint grid of unit squares that runs from x equal to negative 4 to 4 and from y equal to negative 3 to 3. The x-axis has tick marks at every whole number from negative 3 to 3 except 0. A diamond-shaped quadrilateral joins four labeled points in order: 0 comma 3 at the top, 4 comma 0 on the right, 0 comma negative 3 at the bottom, and negative 4 comma 0 on the left. No points inside it are marked.
- Hint 1
The coordinate axes divide the diamond into four right triangles.
- Hint 2
Count interior points one horizontal row at a time. At height 1, the right boundary is two-thirds of the way from the top vertex to the right vertex.
Answer
Area: 24 square units. Strictly interior integer-coordinate points: 23.
Full solution
The axes split the quadrilateral into four triangles, each with perpendicular base and height 4 and 3.
Each triangle has area , so the total area is square units.
For an interior integer-coordinate point, its vertical coordinate can only be or .
The rows at heights and contain only boundary vertices, and all other integer-height rows are outside.
At height 0, the horizontal coordinate is strictly between and , giving 7 points.
Moving from the top vertex down toward the horizontal axis, the width grows in direct proportion to the vertical distance traveled.
At height 1, the right and left boundaries are and , so the possible horizontal coordinates are : 5 points.
At height 2, the boundaries are and , giving 3 points.
Reflection across the horizontal axis gives another 5 and 3 points at heights and .
Thus the count is
The strict inequalities exclude all boundary points.
Answer
Area: 24 square units. Strictly interior integer-coordinate points: 23.
Key idea
A geometric counting problem often becomes manageable when divided into rows.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 4 The best open box
Difficulty: 2 of 3 stars, Challenge
A 12 cm by 12 cm square of cardboard is turned into an open box. A square of side cm is removed from each corner, and the four remaining flaps are folded upward at right angles.
The cut size must be a positive whole number, and the box must have a positive base length. Ignore cardboard thickness.
(a) Which cut size gives the largest volume? State the box dimensions and prove that your choice is best among all allowed cuts.
(b) Which cut size gives the greatest surface area of the open box? Count the base and four walls once each; do not count an inside and an outside separately. Find that area and explain why the cut maximizing volume need not maximize surface area.
Shaded corners are removed. Not to scale. Text description of this figure
A square piece of cardboard whose bottom edge is marked 12 cm. A small shaded square sits in each of its four corners, and the width of the top-left one is marked x. A dashed square, joining the inner corners of the four shaded squares, outlines the middle region, which is labeled base. The shaded corner squares are the pieces that are removed. The drawing is not to scale.
- Hint 1
Each side of the base loses cm at both ends.
- Hint 2
There are five allowed whole-number cut sizes. For surface area, think about the cardboard that remains after the four corner squares are removed.
Answer
(a) Cut out 2 cm squares: an 8 cm by 8 cm by 2 cm box, with volume 128 cubic centimeters. (b) Cut out 1 cm squares: surface area 140 square centimeters.
Full solution
Removing two corner lengths from each side leaves a square base of side cm.
Folding raises the walls to height cm, so the volume is cubic centimeters.
The cut must satisfy and .
Because is a whole number, the only possibilities are 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5.
A cut of 6 would leave no base, so it is not an allowed box.
For , the volume is
For , it is
For , it is
The remaining choices give and cubic centimeters.
The largest value is 128, achieved only by .
This is a proof of the maximum because the list includes every permitted cut size.
Increasing the wall height helps volume, but shrinking the base works in the opposite direction; the two effects must be considered together.
For part (b), folding does not change the area of the remaining cardboard.
The base and four walls together have area square centimeters.
As the positive cut size increases, more cardboard is removed, so this area is largest at , giving square centimeters.
Volume depends on both base size and height, while surface area here measures remaining cardboard; these are different objectives and have different optimal cuts.
Answer
(a) Cut out 2 cm squares: an 8 cm by 8 cm by 2 cm box, with volume 128 cubic centimeters. (b) Cut out 1 cm squares: surface area 140 square centimeters.
Key idea
State exactly what is being optimized: the same set of shapes can have different volume and surface-area winners.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 5 Area matches the notched boundary
Difficulty: 2 of 3 stars, Challenge
A rectangle has whole-number side lengths cm and cm, each at least 3 cm. Remove a 1 cm by 1 cm square from each of its four corners.
The area of the remaining shape, in square centimeters, is numerically equal to the length of its entire boundary, in centimeters. Find every possible pair of original side lengths. Treat a rotated rectangle as the same answer, and prove your list is complete.
- Hint 1
At each corner, compare the total length of boundary removed with the total length newly exposed.
- Hint 2
After expressing the area condition, consider the product .
Answer
The original rectangle is either 3 cm by 10 cm or 4 cm by 6 cm.
Full solution
At one corner, the cut removes two original boundary segments of length 1 cm.
It exposes two new segments, also of length 1 cm.
The total boundary length does not change.
This works at all four corners, so the remaining perimeter is cm.
The four removed squares have total area 4 square centimeters.
The stated numerical equality is therefore , or
Adding 4 to both sides gives
This rearrangement turns the geometric condition into a factor problem.
Both factors are positive whole numbers because and are at least 3.
Ignoring order, the only positive factor pairs of 8 are 1 and 8, or 2 and 4.
Adding 2 to each factor gives side pairs and .
Both work: their remaining areas are and , while their boundary lengths are and .
The exhaustive factor list proves there are no other rectangles.
Answer
The original rectangle is either 3 cm by 10 cm or 4 cm by 6 cm.
Key idea
Translate geometric invariance into a factor equation to classify every possibility.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 6 Does the water cover the cube?
Difficulty: 2 of 3 stars, Challenge
A vertical rectangular tank has an inside base of 10 cm by 10 cm and is tall enough that no water can overflow. It initially contains water to a depth of 4 cm. A solid, waterproof cube with side length 6 cm is lowered into the water until it rests flat on the bottom. No water is lost.
(a) Find the final water depth exactly, and justify whether the cube is completely covered.
(b) What initial water depth would make the final water surface exactly level with the cube's top?
- Hint 1
First calculate how much water fits around the cube up to a height of 6 cm.
- Hint 2
Below the top of the cube, the water occupies a base area of . Above it, water occupies the full base area of 100.
Answer
Final depth: cm, or 6.16 cm; the cube is covered. Required initial depth in part (b): cm, or 3.84 cm.
Full solution
The initial water volume is cubic centimeters.
Up to the cube's top, the available horizontal area for water is the tank's base area minus the cube's footprint: square centimeters.
Water reaching exactly to the cube's 6 cm top would therefore occupy cubic centimeters.
Since 400 is greater than 384, the cube must be fully covered.
There are cubic centimeters of water above its top.
Above the cube, that excess spreads across the full 100-square-centimeter base area.
Its depth is cm.
The final depth is therefore cm.
Notice that using the 64-square-centimeter water area at every height would give the wrong answer once the water rises above the cube.
For part (b), the needed water volume is exactly 384 cubic centimeters.
Before the cube is inserted, that water covers the entire tank base, giving initial depth cm.
Answer
Final depth: cm, or 6.16 cm; the cube is covered. Required initial depth in part (b): cm, or 3.84 cm.
Key idea
Check which geometric case applies before using a volume formula.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 7 A ring with matching measurements
Difficulty: 2 of 3 stars, Challenge
Two circles with the same center have radii cm and cm, where . They bound a ring-shaped region. Remove a sector of this ring by cutting along two radii; the removed angle is greater than and less than .
For the remaining region, its area in square centimeters is numerically equal to the combined length, in centimeters, of its two curved boundary arcs. Do not include the two straight cut edges in that length.
What must the width of the ring be? Prove that your answer works for every allowed choice of removed angle.
- Hint 1
Let be the fraction of the full ring that remains. The same fraction applies to both circumferences.
- Hint 2
Use , then compare the area and arc-length expressions.
Answer
The ring must have width 2 cm, and every such ring satisfies the condition for every allowed removed angle.
Full solution
Let be the fraction of a full turn that remains after the cut.
The restrictions on the angle guarantee .
The remaining area is square centimeters, because it is the same fraction of the outer disk's area minus the inner disk's area.
The combined curved length is cm.
Equating the numerical values and writing the difference of squares as a product gives
The common factor is positive, so division by it is valid.
We obtain .
Conversely, if the width is 2 cm, substituting makes the two expressions identical for every between 0 and 1.
Thus the width condition is both necessary and sufficient.
The conclusion concerns numerical values measured in the specified units; it does not identify area and length as the same kind of measurement.
Answer
The ring must have width 2 cm, and every such ring satisfies the condition for every allowed removed angle.
Key idea
A shared scale factor can disappear, revealing what really controls a relationship.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 8 Half of the painted cubes?
Difficulty: 3 of 3 stars, Deep challenge
A large cube is painted on all six outside faces. It is then cut into an by by grid of identical small cubes, where is a whole number at least 2.
Consider only the small cubes that have at least one painted face. Is it possible that exactly half of these have exactly one painted face? Find every possible , or prove that there is no such .
- Hint 1
Classify the painted cubes as face-interior cubes, edge-interior cubes, and corner cubes.
- Hint 2
If exactly half have one painted face, their number must equal the number having two or three painted faces. Compare divisibility by 3.
Answer
There is no whole number satisfying the condition.
Full solution
On each large face, the cubes with exactly one painted face form an interior square of side .
There are therefore such cubes.
This count is always divisible by 3, including the value 0 when .
A cube with exactly two painted faces lies on a large edge but not at a corner.
The large cube has 12 edges, each contributing such cubes, for a total of .
Exactly three painted faces occur on the 8 corner cubes.
These categories are disjoint and include every painted cube.
Consequently, the number with two or three painted faces is .
When divided by 3, this number leaves remainder 2: the first term is divisible by 3, while 8 leaves remainder 2.
If exactly half of the painted cubes had one painted face, their number would equal the number in the other two categories.
A multiple of 3 cannot equal a number leaving remainder 2 on division by 3.
This contradiction rules out every allowed ; no trial of large cube sizes is needed.
Answer
There is no whole number satisfying the condition.
Key idea
Divisibility can rule out an entire family of geometric constructions.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 9 Recovering an integer rectangle
Difficulty: 3 of 3 stars, Deep challenge
One horizontal segment and one vertical segment divide a rectangle into four smaller rectangles. The top-left, top-right, and bottom-right areas are 18, 30, and 45 square centimeters, respectively.
Both column widths and both row heights are positive whole numbers of centimeters.
(a) Find the bottom-left area.
(b) Find every possible pair of dimensions for the original rectangle, and determine its smallest possible perimeter. Prove that your list is complete.
Areas in square centimeters. Not to scale. Text description of this figure
A rectangle is divided into four smaller rectangles by one vertical line and one horizontal line, each running all the way across it. The area of each small rectangle, in square centimeters, is written inside it: 18 in the top left, 30 in the top right, 45 in the bottom right, and a question mark in the bottom left. No side lengths are labeled, and the drawing is not to scale.
- Hint 1
The ratio of the bottom-row height to the top-row height can be read from the two right-hand areas.
- Hint 2
The right column's width must divide both 30 and 45. Which of its possible values also makes the left width a whole number?
Answer
Missing area: 27 square centimeters. Original dimensions: 8 cm by 15 cm, or 24 cm by 5 cm. Minimum perimeter: 46 cm.
Full solution
The right-hand rectangles share their width, so the ratio of bottom height to top height is .
This same ratio holds in the left column.
Its bottom area is therefore square centimeters.
The total area is 120 square centimeters.
Let the right column's width be cm.
Because the row heights are whole numbers, must be a positive divisor of both 30 and 45.
Its only possibilities are 1, 3, 5, and 15.
The top height is .
Dividing the top-left area by that height gives left width
This is a whole number only for or among the listed choices.
If , the left width is 3 and the row heights are 6 and 9.
The whole rectangle is 8 by 15, with perimeter 46 cm.
If , the left width is 9 and the heights are 2 and 3.
The whole rectangle is 24 by 5, with perimeter 58 cm.
Both constructions realize every given area and integer requirement.
Since all common divisors were checked, the list is complete, and 46 cm is the minimum.
Answer
Missing area: 27 square centimeters. Original dimensions: 8 cm by 15 cm, or 24 cm by 5 cm. Minimum perimeter: 46 cm.
Key idea
Shared dimensions turn area information into ratios and divisibility restrictions.
- Hint 1
-
Problem 10 Enough area, but can it be tiled?
Difficulty: 3 of 3 stars, Deep challenge
A 14 cm by 18 cm rectangle is divided into a grid of 1 cm squares. You have unlimited 1 cm by 4 cm rectangular tiles. A tile may be placed horizontally or vertically, but every tile must follow the grid lines. Tiles cannot overlap, extend outside the rectangle, or be cut.
Can the rectangle be covered exactly? Give a proof. Its area is divisible by 4, so an area calculation alone does not settle the question.
Text description of this figure
A rectangle ruled into a grid of 1 cm squares, with its bottom edge labeled 18 cm and its left edge labeled 14 cm. None of the squares is colored. To the right of the rectangle is a single lightly shaded tile, a strip of four unit squares in a row, labeled as a 1 by 4 tile.
- Hint 1
An ordinary coloring that alternates every 1 cm square does not distinguish the tiles from the board. Try a larger repeating coloring.
- Hint 2
Divide the board into 2 cm by 2 cm blocks, and color those blocks alternately dark and light. Count the unit squares of each color.
Answer
No exact tiling is possible.
Full solution
Group the unit squares into a 7 by 9 array of 2 cm by 2 cm blocks.
Color the blocks in an alternating dark-and-light pattern, like a checkerboard, starting with a dark corner.
Each block contains four unit squares of its color.
There are 63 blocks.
Because both 7 and 9 are odd, the alternating pattern has 32 dark blocks and 31 light blocks.
One way to see this is that successive rows have 5 and 4 dark blocks: four rows contribute 5 each and three rows contribute 4 each.
The board therefore has 128 dark unit squares and 124 light unit squares.
Along any fixed row, colors repeat in runs of two: dark, dark, light, light, and so on, possibly starting at another position in the pattern.
Any four consecutive squares contain two of each color.
The same is true along each column.
Every allowed tile therefore covers exactly two dark and two light squares, even if its ends do not align with the 2 cm blocks.
Any collection of these tiles covers equal numbers of dark and light squares.
The board has unequal numbers, so no exact covering exists.
Although the area would require 63 tiles, the coloring reveals an additional obstruction.
Answer
No exact tiling is possible.
Key idea
A useful coloring records information that area alone cannot detect.
- Hint 1